Is Getting a Supplier’s Choice for a Rental Car a Good Idea?

When booking a rental car, you might encounter offers like Supplier's Choice, Manager's Choice, or Manager's Special. These terms refer to a rental option where the supplier selects the vehicle for you, based on the category you’ve chosen. In some cases, this is a random selection, while in others, it could be a specific type of vehicle like an electric vehicle (EV). Let’s break down the pros and cons of each option to help you decide if it’s the right choice for your next trip.

The Pros of Supplier’s Choice

Choosing Supplier’s Choice can be a great way to save money on your car rental. With this option, you typically pay a lower rate than if you specifically reserved a certain model in advance. This is because the supplier selects the car for you based on availability, helping them optimize their fleet management. An added advantage is the potential for a surprise upgrade. If the supplier has an excess of higher-end models, you might end up driving a more luxurious or spacious car at no additional cost.

This option is especially beneficial during high-demand periods when car availability might be limited. Opting for Supplier’s Choice ensures you have a vehicle secured without the hassle of browsing through categories. It’s also convenient for travelers who are flexible and don’t have a strong preference for a specific car model, as it allows you to focus more on enjoying your trip than worrying about vehicle specifics.

Additionally, Supplier’s Choice can introduce you to new models or car types you might not have chosen yourself, adding an element of surprise to your journey. This flexibility, combined with the potential for savings and convenience, makes Supplier’s Choice an excellent option for budget-conscious or adventurous travelers looking for a hassle-free car rental experience.

The Cons of Supplier’s Choice

The main consideration with Supplier’s Choice is the element of surprise. While you may not know the exact vehicle you’ll be driving until pickup, this option can offer exciting possibilities and flexibility. However, if you have specific requirements, such as needing extra luggage space or a particular vehicle type, it’s important to note that the assigned car might differ from your expectations. For instance, travelers with families who need a larger car could potentially receive a more compact option.

Is It Right for You?

In the end, choosing Supplier’s Choice, Manager’s Choice, or Manager’s Special depends on your travel priorities. If you're flexible, looking for savings, and open to surprises, these options can be a great deal. However, if you have specific needs or preferences, it’s better to book a specific model in advance to avoid any surprises at the rental desk. For those traveling during busy seasons or those who simply want to save money without worrying about the specifics, these options can be a great way to secure a car and maybe even get an upgrade. But for those who prefer certainty and control over the vehicle they’ll be driving, it’s often worth booking a specific car in advance.